Eloquence for Linux anyone?
Loading reactions…
Diego Gomez
https://github.com/Mudb0y/Apple-Eloquence-ELF
Loading reactions…
Doug Lee
There is at least one legal Eloquence-type synth for Linux but it is not quite free, though I think it is not expensive. Sadly I don't have the details to hand. Do you know the legal status of the GitHub project you posted here?
Loading reactions…
Diego Gomez
I’m not sure about that. You’d probably have to ask the owner of the project.
Loading reactions…
Diego Gomez
Then again, we gotta remember that it didn’t always start this way I don’t think. It started with the Level Star Icon.
Loading reactions…
Dane Stange
Ah, Doug Lee — classic accessibility dev. He asks good questions. The honest answer on legal status for Mudb0y's `apple-eloquence-elf`: **It's technically a DMCA gray area.** The repo doesn't commit the converted `.so` files (the `prebuilt/` directory is gitignored). Users extract their own binaries from Apple's tvOS Simulator Runtime (which they have a legal right to download as Apple Developer Program members or anyone who's accepted Apple's SDK terms). The `macho2elf.py` converter itself is original code (MIT licensed), not a copy of anything proprietary. So Mudb0y's approach is carefully designed: provide the **tool** (converter + speech-dispatcher module), let users provide the **payload** (Apple's dylibs extracted from their own legally obtained SDK image). Same pattern as emulator projects that distribute the emulator but not the ROMs. The "legal Eloquence-type synth for Linux" Doug mentions could be one of: - **Voxin** — was the licensed option via Oralux, but shutdown in 2026 - **Code Factory Linux** — exists but is essentially abandoned and barely functional - Maybe some enterprise Cerence Linux build that's not consumer-facing Doug's right that none are free and most are vaporware at this point. The community-built path is what actually works.
Loading reactions…
Diego Gomez
That’s a good point. Honestly, that question has been going on for probably more than 20 years at this point. Otherwise, I don’t think Apple would’ve gotten it into their own hands.
Loading reactions…
Dane Stange
Eloquence is probably the most resilient proprietary software on Earth. It has: - **Four independent binary lineages** (arm32 Levelstar, i386 Voxin/IBM, aarch64 Apple, x86_64 Apple) - **A living build pipeline** (Apple compiles fresh binaries every year) - **Converter tools that work** (macho2elf.py → any ELF platform) - **A public-domain synthesizer algorithm** (Klatt can be reimplemented clean-room) - **A community that's maintained it for 15+ years** with zero corporate support - **No viable replacement** for its core use case Time catches up to everything eventually. But Eloquence has already outlived ETI, SpeechWorks, ScanSoft, Nuance, and the 32-bit era. It'll probably outlive Cerence too. When Cerence eventually gets acquired or dissolved, the Apple licensing deal will just transfer to whoever buys the IP — or Apple will have perpetual rights. The cockroach of speech synthesis. It's not going anywhere. 🪳
Loading reactions…
Dane Stange
I wonder if there are any other eloquence obsessed on, `0 rambliauhrhrhr?
Loading reactions…
Diego Gomez
Same.
Loading reactions…