Skip to main content
Ramblio
  • cyco

    I have never heard blindness be call a spectrum. I have always heard the different types of blindness.

    Loading reactions…

  • cyco

    I didn’t hear anything wrong with what you said in your post.

    Loading reactions…

  • Callum

    I’m very curious to see what others have to say because I think it’s a very interesting topic. I was born completely blind without any sight or light perception which makes me one of the rarest categories of blindness, I’m like a red diamond or fields disease I suppose but even then I don’t think gatekeeping the term blindness is particularly sensible because everyone has their own lived experience and if they feel blindness is the right term for them I don’t really see how others have standing to comment, and selfishly. I don’t want the blind community to be smaller because larger communities tend to get more done for their members. Besides which, there are people who have some sight who prefer to use VoiceOver and braille for all kinds of reasons. And I Guess you can draw all kinds of arbitrary lines in the sand as to who counts as blind and who doesn’t but I’m not sure how practical or useful that would be.

    Loading reactions…

  • The Tone Smith

    Replying to  @Pikachu: Audio

    Loading reactions…

  • Doug Lee

    This has never been a huge deal for me one way or the other, but I think the problems you point out are more about perception than label. "Blind," to me, is ideally synonymous with the term "legally blind" in the US. You effectively caused me to notice that countries differ on the definition of "blind," and specifically on the requirements for being counted as "blind." But you also point out that laypeople are thinking of "blind" as total. To me, that's the biggest problem, not the actual term used. This is a highly nuanced issue though. For example, one complaint I've seen about separating "blind" from "partially sighted" is that it can tend to make a hierarchy. One of my college friends many years ago codified this: Her friend group coined terms like "HAMP" for "high and mighty partial," and "LAMP" for "low and mighty partial." No joke! Anyway, the effect of that sort of hierarchical view can be to minimize those with less sight, which is the opposite of what I think you want.

    Loading reactions…

  • The Tone Smith

    Replying to  @gabeuser845680: Audio

    Loading reactions…

  • Stephanie

    I have no problems with this. It explains the different levels for those who may not know. I would not call it a spectrum; it's just a way of describing how much sight someone may have. By the way, lived experience is totallifferent for a blind person. and blindness organizations still very favour those with low vision, at least here in Australia.

    Loading reactions…

  • Callum

    Replying to  @IAmTheTonesmith: Audio

    But I don’t think the experiences are really that different because Vision is such a strange thing and Vision loss is strange, like people can see things which are far away but have trouble with things that are nearby and vice versa, some people may use their eyes first but still rely on meta smart glasses for a clearer picture of what they’re looking at, or use braille because using their eyesight can cause eye strain, not to mension so many eye conditions are progressive so like at what point can someone say I wasn’t blind yesterday, but I’m blind today

    Loading reactions…

  • Pikachu Purr Ever

    Replying to  @IAmTheTonesmith: Audio

    Loading reactions…

  • The Tone Smith

    Replying to  @Pikachu: Audio

    Loading reactions…

  • Estelliarmus

    I haven't listened to the audio comments, so forgive me if this has already come up. I was having a related conversation yesterday, but it occured to me how much of a deliniation there is between what I will call braille users and functional partials. The issue in South Africa is that blindness organisations are by and large run by blind people, and blind volunteers. And it means that often, when discussing blindness issues, we tend to inadvertently miss the issues effecting functional partials, because we don't understand them, can't relate to them and don't know what accommodations they would need. It also came up that the life of a functional partial must be incredibly difficult. Because on the one hand, you have sighted people assuming competence, which is — I know — what so many of the fully blind contingent wish for. But on the other hand, you are often (Not always), in a position of needing to disclose. Disclosing that you need help, why you need it, what you need, why you may need it in bright light but not in a shopping center, or vice versa. It must be so damn frustrating. And I can't help but to feel lucky in some ways. I'd love for sighted people to assume I'm competent, but mostly that has to do with the fact that I am a very anxious person and I hate the thought of putting people out in any way. I think that sometimes the catch-all term "blind" has a specific meaning, and to the detriment of the full community it attempts to serve.

    Loading reactions…

  • Travs could

    Replying to  @Callumity: I’m very curious to see what others have to say because I think it’s a very inte

    I couldn't help myself, but of course you don't see it, mate of course you don't 🤣

    Loading reactions…

  • Pikachu Purr Ever

    Replying to  @IAmTheTonesmith: Audio

    Loading reactions…

  • Dan 26

    I don’t think this is enables post. But I think you are internalizing some of the political arguments that are ultimately ablest. It is literally a spectrum, which is why terms like partially cited or partially blind are used. Ultimately, I think pitting disabled people against each other by gatekeeping the “resource pool“ is exactly what those who believe we are a drag on society want.

    Loading reactions…

  • DAJones

    Loading reactions…

  • Doug Lee

    Replying to  @DAJones69: Audio

    You describe pretty accurately the whole idea behind "legally blind" at least in the US: You are supposed to be "legally blind" if your lack of sight is sufficient to impair you in such very real ways as you mention. Countries do seem to differ though on how to draw that line. I would argue that it's very hard to get that right across the board, but that this doesn't take away from the validity of needing to try.

    Loading reactions…

  • The Tone Smith

    Replying to  @tardis: Audio

    Loading reactions…

  • The Tone Smith

    Replying to  @Pikachu: Audio

    Loading reactions…

  • The Tone Smith

    Replying to  @Dan: I don’t think this is enables post. But I think you are internalizing some of th

    I think Pikachu said it best. Vision loss is a spectrum, blindness isn't. I think it could be as simple as using the correct language. When influences on TikTok and other platforms say that blindness is a spectrum, that distorts the truth because the word blind actually means complete or near complete vision loss. Perhaps we need to encourage people to talk about vision loss as a spectrum instead.

    Loading reactions…

  • The Tone Smith

    Replying to  @DAJones69: Audio

    Loading reactions…

  • Pikachu Purr Ever

    Replying to  @IAmTheTonesmith: Audio

    Loading reactions…

Log in to comment